by Joshua Cohen

    “Turnbull’s Blue—Antwerp Blue—Berlin Blue—Prussiate of Iron—Chinese Blue—Saxon Blue—Blau de Berlin”: Reading the world’s first artificial color.







    Artists in the West had no reliable blue until the early eighteenth century. Ultramarine, extracted from the blue stone called lapis lazuli, was said to have once been more expensive than gold, and Renaissance artists had to negotiate with their patrons for individual drops of blue upon receiving their commissions (ultramarine means, literally, “over the sea,” because most lapis was imported from Afghanistan). Indigo, derived from plants of the Indigofera genus, tended to blacken, and was not lightfast, while azurite, derived from the mineral of the same name, turned green when mixed with water, and so was unusable for frescoes, which were painted affresco, translating to “fresh,” with the implication of “wet.” Smalt, a ground glass colored with cobalt, would fade, and the chemical properties of copper were not yet understood; there was no way to consistently create blue from that metal, as opposed to green, or a tint somewhere between. It is commonly agreed that “Prussian blue”—the painter’s first stable blue—was the palette's first synthesized color: Fe(CN)18(H2O)x, where 14 ≤ x ≤ 16…

    What follows is a portrait of that color—or a “blueprint,” of its origins and use—through chemistry, painting, photography, industry, warfare, Holocaust, and nuclear terrorism.



    blue n. The hue of that portion of the visible spectrum lying between green and indigo, evoked in the human observer by radiant energy with wavelengths of approximately 420 to 490 nanometers; any of a group of colors that may vary in lightness and saturation, whose hue is that of a clear daytime sky; one of the additive or light primaries; one of the psychological primary hues.

    —American Heritage Dictionary
    of the English Language
    ,
    fourth edition




    Prussian Blue: Turnbull’s Blue—Antwerp Blue—Berlin Blue—Prussiate of Iron—Chinese Blue—Saxon Blue—Bleu de Berlin—Pariser-blau


    —Arthur Herbert Church, The Chemistry of Paints and Painting


    It has been alleged, that the ancients were acquainted with Prussian blue, which they employed in painting; but Landriani has shown, in his dissertation on this substance, from the evidence of Theophrastus and Pliny, and from the analysis of an Egyptian mummy, that the ancients employed ultramarine blue and the smalt or azure of cobalt; and that Prussian blue, which is readily acted on by the substances to which it must have been exposed in these countries, could not have resisted their influence for so many ages, and retain the beautiful colours, which are admired in the paintings of Herculaneum.

    Stahl relates, in his 300 experiments, that the discovery of Prussian blue was owing to an accident. About the beginning of the 18th century, Diesbach, a chemist of Berlin, wishing to precipitate a decoction of cochineal with an alkali, borrowed from Dippel some potash, on which he had distilled several times his animal oil; but as there was some sulphate of iron in the decoction of cochineal, the liquor instantly exhibited a beautiful blue in place of a red precipitate. Reflecting on the circumstances which had taken place, he found that it was easy to produce at pleasure the same substance, which afterwards became an object of commerce.


    —Encyclopedia Britannica, sixth edition



    The earliest painting on which De Wilde reports [Prussian blue] is one by J. E. La Farque, dated 1770.

    —Rutherford John Gettens and George Leslie Stout, Painting Materials: A Short Encyclopedia


    A number of apparently old paintings have been betrayed by the presence of Prussian Blue: and Entrance to the Cannaregio once firmly attributed to Francesco Guardi was hurriedly relabeled “Imitator of Guardi” when it was found to contain Cobalt Blue, invented nine years after Guardi’s death.

    —David Bomford, The History of Colour in Art



    The pigment was accepted by artists much earlier than previously assumed, as can be proven on the basis of a number of examples. To date, the painting Entombment of Christ (Picture Gallery, Sanssouci, Potsdam, dated 1709) by Pieter van der Werff is the oldest known painting that makes use of Prussian blue. Around 1710, painters at the Prussian court such as Pesne, Gericke, Manyóki, and Weidemann were already using the pigment to a surprisingly large extent. At around the same time, Prussian blue arrived in Paris, where Watteau and later his successors Lancret and Pater used it in their paintings.

    —Jens Bartoll, The Early Use of Prussian Blue in Paintings

    Dippel’s Animal Oil: Johann Konrad Dippel (1673-1734) was born at Castle Frankenstein near Darmstadt, the son of a Lutheran pastor. He became a master theologian, publishing under the name Christianus Democritus, but succumbed to the lure of alchemy, signing himself Frankensteinensis. Having failed to make gold, he launched his elixir vitae—a medicinal “animal oil”—upon an unsuspecting public in 1700. Dippel’s oil was a malodorous distillate of the unconsidered residues of animal carcasses—blood, bones and offal. His predilection for body parts may have later inspired Mary Shelley, when she visited Castle Frankenstein in 1814, on her elopement with Percy. We now know Dippel’s oil to consist of a mixture of nitrogenous organic bases such as pyrrole, and several alkyl cyanides. At the time it was hailed as a panacea—presumably sustained by the widely-held belief that anything so obnoxious must be beneficial. In 1704 Dippel supplied the artists’ colourmaker, Heinrich Diesbach of Berlin, with an impure sample of alkali that was contaminated with his oil. By chance, this provided the essential ingredient—cyanide—to enable Diesbach’s serendipitous discovery of the first synthetic pigment, Prussian blue or Turnbull’s blue. All painters thereafter have reason to be grateful to this unscrupulous alchemist, who, after numerous scrapes with European royalty, died at Castle Wittgenstein, possibly a victim of his own elixir.

    —Roger Jones, What’s Who?
    A Dictionary of Things Named After People
    and the People They Are Named After



    Dry thoroughly in an iron vessel and powder grossly, any quantity of fresh blood. Dry thoroughly and powder also a quantity of pearl ash equal to the powdered blood. Mix them, and calcine them in a low red heat in a crucible with a loose cover until all smoke and flame ceases: then make the cover fit close, and calcine in a full red or nearly white heat for half an hour. The crucible should not be more than two thirds full, as the mixture is apt to swell. Empty the contents of the crucible into warm water in the proportion of a quart to four oz. of the mixture. Pour on again as much warm water: mix and filter the solutions. Dissolve of sulphat of iron (green vitriol) and of alum, of each a quantity equal to one half of the pearl ash employed. Pour the solution of alum and green vitriol mixt together, gradually into the solution of blood and alkali: both solutions are better for being warm, but not boiling hot. Stir it well. Let the sediment settle. It will be of a dirty greenish colour: wash it. Then digest it for 2 or 3 days in diluted muriatic acid (spirit of salt one part, water two parts). The colour by this means gradually becomes blue, because the muriatic acid dissolves the yellow oxyd of iron which is not combined with the prussic acid. Wash it repeatedly. Dry it on chalk stones, paper, linen, or any other mode of draining off the water. Spread it thin to expose it to the air. I have kept the lixivium of blood and alkali (prussiat of potash) for a year and a half in bottles, and used it to make prussian blue with equal success as at first. Chippings of hoofs answer equally well with blood.

    —John Redman Coxe and Thomas Cooper,
    The Emporium of Arts and Sciences



    The colours which approach the dark side, and consequently, blue in particular, can be made to approximate to black; in fact, a very perfect Prussian blue, or an indigo acted on by vitriolic acid appears almost as a black.

    —Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, Theory of Colors



    Shall the names of so many of our colors continue to be derived from those of obscure foreign localities, as Naples yellow, Prussian blue, raw Sienna, burnt Umber, Gamboge? (surely the Tyrian purple must have faded by this time), or from comparatively trivial articles of commerce,—chocolate, lemon, coffee, cinnamon, claret? (shall we compare our hickory to a lemon, or a lemon to a hickory?) or from ores and oxides which few ever see?

    —Henry David Thoreau, Autumnal Tints



    As a manufactured color, Prussian blue, like Naples yellow, Turner’s yellow, and Scheele’s green, involved materials and production methods that crossed the traditional boundaries of several groups: colormakers, apothecaries, drysalters, and manufacturing chemists. Production rights were frequently in dispute. In France, sale of painters’ materials was a responsibility of the painters’ guild (the Académie de St-Luc). Manufactured colors, when they did not use traditional coloring materials or did not use them in traditional ways, threatened this closely guarded right. In 1764, masters from the Académie de St-Luc seized the Prussian blue factory of sieurs Gly and d’Heure. The owners turned to the Paris Academy of Sciences, asking for a determination of the nature of Prussian blue. Gly and d’Heure argued that theirs was a chemical factory with no connection to the art of painting, even though painters used their product. Jean Hellot examined the problem on behalf of the Academy, and agreed with the manufacturers. Prussian blue is a product of chemistry and should not be controlled by the painters’ guild. The factory in the faubourg Saint-Marcel was allowed to reopen and continued to make Prussian blue through the next four decades; theirs was often considered the best that was made in Paris.

    —Sarah Lowengard, The Creation of
    Color in Eighteenth-Century Europe



    Prooshan Blue. A term of great endearment. After the battle of Waterloo the Prussians were immensely popular in England, and in connection with the Loyal True Blue Club gave rise to the toasts, “The True Blue” and the “Prussian Blue.” Sam Weller [Dickens’s Pickwick Papers] addresses his father with “Vell, my Prooshan Blue.”

    —Brewer’s Dictionary

    Rossetti walked round Ruskin’s class-room one evening, when the latter was absent. “How’s this?” he said; “nothing but blue studies—can’t any of you see any colour but blue?” “It was by Mr. Ruskin’s directions,” one of the students answered. “Well, where do you get all this Prussian blue from?” asked Rossetti; and then, opening a cupboard, “Well, I declare, here’s a packet with several dozen cakes of this fearful colour. Oh, I can’t allow it; Mr. Ruskin will spoil everybody’s eye for colour—I shall confiscate the whole lot; I must do it, in the interests of his and my pupils. You must tell him that I’ve taken them all away.” When a few evenings later Ruskin was told what had happened, he “burst into one of those boisterous laughs in which he indulged whenever anything very much amused him.”

    —Edward Cook, The Life of John Ruskin



    A simple blue sky: Prussian Blue, Antwerp Blue or Cobalt Blue.

    Grass in shadow: Prussian Blue and Indian Red; or Prussian Blue and Burnt Sienna. Aurora Yellow and Prussian Blue gives a green color similar to Emerald.


    —Cyclopedia of Drawing, ed. Alfred E. Zapf


    This Prussian blue is the most subtle and invading color on the palette. It is like those articles marked “made in Germany,” which go everywhere. It was the cause of the ruder manifestations of French esprit being abandoned in the Atelier Picot. This is the tradition: A new student one day was stripped, tied to a ladder, painted all over with Prussian blue, and then set out in the street, leaning against a wall. One can easily imagine how the police went into the matter, and one acquainted with Prussian blue can imagine how they came out. The whole quarter must have been tinged with blue.

    —Elihu Vedder, Reminiscences of an American Painter



    And that is how I caught Cézanne off guard, coming along bent over in thought. His face like a potter’s, sun-burned, looked startled as the shadow of nearby leaves played over it. He had a small, bony head with rosy skin, lively eyes, and a white mustache, carelessly smeared with prussian blue.

    —Jules Borély, Conversations with Cézanne

    One should not work Prussian blue into one’s drawing of a face; for then it ceases to be flesh and becomes wood.

    —Vincent van Gogh, in a letter
    to his brother Theo


    Mr. Wordsworth loved all that was rich and picturesque, light and free, in clothing. A deep Prussian blue, or purple, was one of his favourite colours for a silk dress.

    —Memoirs of Sara Coleridge



    Paper simply washed with a solution of this salt is highly sensitive to the action of light. Prussian blue is deposited (the base being necessarily supplied by the destruction of one portion of the acid, and the acid by decomposition of another). After half an hour or an hour’s exposure to sunshine, a very beautiful negative photograph is the result, to fix which, all that is necessary is to soak it in water in which a little sulphate of soda is dissolved, to insure the fixity of the Prussian blue deposited. While dry the impression is dove colour or lavender-blue, which has a curious and striking effect on the greenish-yellow ground of the paper, produced by the saline solution. After washing, the ground colour disappears, and the photograph becomes bright blue on a white ground. If too long exposed, it gets “over-sunned,” and the tint has a brownish or yellowish tendency, which however is removed in fixing; but no increase of intensity beyond a certain point is obtained by continuance of exposure.

    —Sir J. F. W. Herschel, On the Action of the
    Rays of the Solar Spectrum on Vegetable Colours,
    and on some new Photographic Processes

    I find Prussian blue is the only blue that retains its exact color-cast under artificial light, and since a picture is so often seen in such light, I deem this worthy of consideration.

    —John F. Carlson, Elementary
    Principles of Landscape Painting



    “You only need three colours, you know. Very simple.” “Which colours are they?” I inquire ignorantly. “Why, you know of course,” he says surprised. “Burnt sienna, cadmium yellow, and—er—there! I can't think of it. I know it as well as I know my own face. So do you. Well, that's stupid of me.”

    Or, his worn eyes dwelling benignantly upon my duffle-bag, he warns me (in a low voice) of Prussian Blue.


    —ee cummings, The Enormous Room


    Your hair’s a mass of Prussian blue,
    The helmet of an amazon—
    No thought has ever broken through,
    No blush was ever seen upon
    That brow, encased in Prussian blue.


    —Charles Baudelaire, Rara Avis, or The Nymphomaniad


    Ah, yes—on the darkened parade square there was still a ring of torches and, surprisingly, the strains of military music. There was but one silence, the same for all the skies of prussian blue, and indeed for the plains as well. The dark is so uniquely uniform, so unifying in its uniformity!

    —Max Jacob, The Bouchaballe Property



    National uniform color was simply tradition. At a distance, an army’s colors proved incomprehensible save for the Austrians who wore white and the British who wore red. At cannon shot, Prussian blue was much like French blue, and the Russian green was not distinguishable from either of them. Cavalry regiments were particularly difficult to distinguish at longer range, and friendly fire was a constant threat from enthusiastic gunners.

    —Roman Jarymowycz, Cavalry from Hoof to Track



    You are a hundred thousand times welcome, old wort-sampler, hellbeit you’re just about as culpable as my woolfell merger would be. In effect I could engage in an energument over you till you were republicly royally toobally prussic blue in the shirt after. Trionfante di bestia!

    —James Joyce, Finnegans Wake


    Morally Chichikov was hardly guilty of any special crime in attempting to buy up dead men in a country where live men were lawfully purchased and pawned. If I paint my face with home made Prussian Blue instead of applying the Prussian Blue which is sold by the state and cannot be manufactured by private persons, my crime will be hardly worth a passing smile and no writer will make of it a Prussian tragedy. But if I have surrounded the whole business with a good deal of mystery and flaunted a cleverness that presupposed most intricate difficulties in perpetrating a crime of that kind, and if owing to my letting a garrulous neighbor peep at my pots of home-brewn paint I get arrested and am roughly handled by men with authentic blue faces, then the laugh for what it is worth is on me.

    —Vladimir Nabokov, Nikolai Gogol



    If, for instance, you were ordered to paint a particular shade of blue called “Prussian Blue,” you might have to use a table to lead you from the word “Prussian Blue,” to a sample of the color, which would serve you as your copy.

    —Ludwig Wittgenstein, The Blue Book


    If it is the middle of the day, however, discard the use of umber as a substitute for Prussian blue.

    —Larry Rivers and Frank O’Hara, How to Proceed in the Arts


    Blue, Prussian (usually with black—with yellow for special greens)

    Avoid blue in mixtures because of its imbecile atmospheric tendency


    —Marcel Duchamp, The Bride’s Veil



    Perhaps the most spectacular secret ink is Prussian blue, which forms by means of a chemical reaction between ferric sulfate and potassium ferrocyanide. Generally, a message written with ferric sulfate solution will be revealed when it is sprayed with ferrocyanide. A spy can soak fabric with each of these solutions and transport secret information without detection. During World War II a German spy named George Vaux Bacon made notations on his socks and cloth buttons with the secret ink reagents. He, too, was caught and executed.

    —Joe Schwarcz, The Genie in the Bottle, 67 All-New Commentaries on the Fascinating Chemistry of Everyday Life



    Forensic samples were taken from the visited sites. A control sample was removed from delousing facility 1 at Birkenau. It was postulated that because of the high iron content of the building materials at these camps the presence of hydrogen cyanide gas [Zyklon-B] would result in a ferric-ferro-cyanide compound being formed, as evidenced by the Prussian Blue staining on the walls in the delousing facilities.

    A detailed analysis of the thirty-two samples taken at the Auschwitz-Birkenau complexes showed 1,050 mg/kg of cyanide and 6,170 mg/kg of iron. Higher iron results were found at all of the alleged gas chambers but no significant cyanide traces. This would be impossible if these sites were exposed to hydrogen cyanide gas, because the alleged gas chambers supposedly were exposed to much greater quantities of gas than the delousing facility. Thus, chemical analysis supports the fact that these facilities were never utilized as gas execution facilities.

    —Fred A. Leuchter Jr., The Leuchter Report

    Hydrogen cyanide (HCN), also known as hydrocyanic acid, prussic acid or Blausäure was the toxic agent in Zyklon-B. Strictly speaking, the term hydrogen cyanide should be used for the pure compound and the term hydrocyanic acid reserved for its aqueous solutions, but this convention has been ignored so much that it is pointless to insist upon it. HCN is a high vapor pressure liquid; the Merck index lists its boiling point as 25.6 degrees Celsius (78.8 degrees Fahrenheit), significantly less than human body temperature. At room temperature (25 d C, 77 d F) the equilibrium vapor pressure of HCN is 750 Torr (760 Torr = 1 atmosphere), corresponding to 987,000 ppm. At 0 C (32 F) it is 260 Torr corresponding to 342,000 ppm. The Merck index warns, “Exposure to 150 ppm for 1/2 to 1 hr may endanger life. Death may result from a few min exposure to 300 ppm.” Clearly, it is not necessary to reach equilibrium vapor pressure in order for the fumes of the liquid to be quite deadly.
    […]
    Leuchter’s primary mistake is his initial assumption that exposure to HCN must result in the formation of Prussian blue. Another error is his claim that the delousing facilities were exposed to less HCN than the homicidal chambers. It turns out that it is more difficult to kill lice than it is to kill humans.

    —Richard J. Green, The Chemistry of Auschwitz



    What has the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) determined about Prussian blue?
       The FDA has determined that the 500 mg Prussian blue capsules […] can be found safe and effective for the treatment of known or suspected internal contamination with radioactive cesium, radioactive thallium, or non-radioactive thallium.

    How does Prussian blue work?
       Prussian blue works using a mechanism known as ion exchange. Cesium or thallium that have been absorbed into the body are removed by the liver and passed into the intestine and are then re-absorbed into the body (entero-hepatic circulation). Prussian blue works by trapping thallium and cesium in the intestine, so that they can be passed out of the body in the stool rather than be re-absorbed. If persons are exposed to radioactive cesium, radioactive thallium, or non-radioactive thallium, taking Prussian blue may reduce the risk of death and major illness from radiation or poisoning.

    —FDA/Center for Drug Evaluation and Research,
    “Questions and Answers on Prussian Blue”



    People may have blue feces (stool) during the time that they are taking Prussian blue.

    —Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
    fact sheet on Prussian blue




    Tragically, “Prussian Blue” was the first Crayola-brand crayon to be renamed by the company—becoming “Midnight Blue,” in 1958. This change was prompted by American schoolteachers who found that their students were unfamiliar with the history of Prussia.